Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

>IIRC, PP can be a precursor to chlorine

potassium permanganate does not contain chlorine



No, but muriatic acid does. I'm pretty sure it's a redox reaction.


How is HCl related to KMnO4? And why would one combine them?

Why not just add a hypochlorite to water if the end goal is to disinfect with chlorine?


The allegation is that KMnO₄ is undergoing a redox reaction with HCl to produce Cl₂ gas (which is a plausible redox reaction, given the half-reaction potentials).

But yeah, in practice you're going to disinfect with Cl₂ gas or NaClO. The water plant I worked at switched from Cl₂ to ClO¯ as primary disinfectant, and the operators were all for it. No more need to manually switch out Cl₂ tanks, no more Cl₂ venting issues (spilling NaClO is nowhere near as bad a Cl₂ leak). (The plant also used O₃ for bonus disinfection as well. The operators hated it at first, but now would throw a conniption fit were it broken).


It was a comparison on par with the parent comment's argument. Looking back, it wasn't well constructed on my end and probably led to confusion.

What I was going for was: just because they do the same thing doesn't mean they're the same at all.

HCl + KMnO4 -> KCl + MnCl2 + Cl2 + H2O




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: