Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

It's a very effective meme. Like most such memes, it worms itself inside, and the vehicle doesn't consciously know of its presence. These people aren't thinking "I'll do this. It'll get me votes". It is unconscious mimetic memetics, if you will :)

Some of these memes become elevated into conscious actions. For instance, people cynically exploit "Linux can't do X" to get help for X. But some memes are unconscious and I think "I'll be downvoted for this" or "Get out of here with your facts and reason" or "Source?" are definitely examples of these.

Personally, I think many of the privacy and security comments are also memes that propagate through mimicry of success, but that's its own thing.



Would you mind elaborating on which privacy and security comments you think propagate as memes?


I was with you til the last sentence. Have an upvote


Haha, that was unnecessarily controversial on my part. I can totally accept that other people disagree on that.


but you didn't even add the requisite "go ahead and downvote me!"


They’ve just fallen in with a different meme that makes comments attractive to a different set of users.


Yes, indeed! I can certainly tell you that post The Selfish Gene I have been entirely enamoured of the concept of the meme. I find it very elegant. If that isn't a brainjack, I don't know what is.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: