Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

My impression is that in modern UIs, both checkboxes and option buttons are being phased out: Checkboxes seems to be replaced with apple-style toggle buttons, which I guess are more intuitive for some people?

Option buttons don't have any direct replacement that I can think of, you just see them incredibly rarely. My guess is that they always were one of several possible means to have the user select from a set of choices, the other prominent ones being a plain listbox widget or a combobox/dropdown widget - or of course, just use plain buttons.

For some reason, designers seem to prefer plain buttons or a dropdown for this usecase today.



> apple-style toggle buttons, which I guess are more intuitive for some people?

You seriously overestimate the average competency in UX circles.

The algorithm outside Apple is basically "what would Apple use here?".

The algorithm inside Apple is basically "what will make people talk about us?"

Serious studies are for boring people. Design hipsters don't want to look boring.


Toggles are actually not that bad as a checkbox replacement. But I feel they convey a lot of meaning through color (in iOS, sliders turn green when selected), whereas checkboxes reimain immediate even in b/w. I wonder whether people with severe colour blindness have any issue with that?

Ahh why didn't I take interface design as a career :)




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: