Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Ads haven't always existed. Economies without them can exist and we can move toward one.


Can you explain how a service like YouTube could exist any other way?

> Economies without them can exist

We should be able to both hate ads and understand that they are a necessary monetization model for certain things. If you feel strongly that they aren't necessary what model should be used instead?


Maybe YouTube can't exist without ads but the next thing might.


You can literally pay YouTube to avoid ads, watching the mental gymnastics folks on here do to complain about YouTube Premium is my favorite pastime.


Why would you pay for something that treats you as a product? I would gladly pay for youtube if there was: no paid sponsorships, no ads, no algorythm manipulations, no collection of behavioral information, no clickbaits, no shitty content promoted and so on and so. Basically a service where the side paying is a consumer, not a product. Paying for service that is already extracting value from you in ways that are not respectable is insane.


A well pruned YouTube subscription is right now the highest quality video entertainment and information service in the history of the world. You literally just need to "like and subscribe" to a bunch of high quality videos and YouTube will recommend you a never ending supply of high quality videos. You can then continue to improve your recommendations with the like/dislike buttons.

If you're seeing "shitty content", clickbait and paid sponsorship, it means you haven't told the YouTube algorithm what you want to see. It's just the push of a button.


> no paid sponsorships, no ads, no algorythm manipulations, no collection of behavioral information, no clickbaits, no shitty content promoted

There are plenty of channels that do none of these. As for "algorythm manipulations", YT recommends more of what you like or subscribed to. Not sure what you expect a content aggregator and provider to do. Just have a search bar? I've come across so many interesting channels thanks to the "algorythm manipulations".


I pay for YouTube premium. But it simply would not exist to the same scale or utility if that was the only model that was funding it. Incredible to see the mental gymnastics needed to avoid that fact.


> But it simply would not exist to the same scale or utility if that was the only model that was funding it.

Citation needed. Are you saying that if there were a billion YT premium subscribers, YT would still need ads for its scale? I doubt it.


I almost fail to see what harm could come from nationalizing YouTube at this point.


what adverts does YouTube have?


They have existed since humans could write or talk.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: