Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Revolut [1] does this and while I like their service overall, I hate the login mails. My email box is full of these login mails and it feels like abuse of the email system to me. I have all kinds of alternatives, Yubikey, TOTP, Password Manager etc. - everything would be better than this magic login link.

[1]: https://www.revolut.com



So in case of temporary email delivery problem no banking?

I had this case recently: Sending a job application, so wanting to check what my LinkedIn actually says (I don't use or even update LinkedIn regularly). Now LinkedIn thinks my login looks suspicious and sends a confirmation email. (It does that nearly every time the rare cases I log in, probably because I delete cookies.) But the mail doesn't arrive. My email provider is usually very reliable, but later I learned that just in this moment they experienced multi-hour delays. While this was not a magic link it shows that any login requiring a quick email delivery can fail in the worst moment.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: