Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

There's a very, very long standing specific exception for members of the military (subject to the UCMJ) that is not present for teachers.


[flagged]


> non-political government office holders ought to not weigh in on politics

They have the clear First Amendment right to do so on their own time.

I mean, I hold the opinion that people "ought not to" be fans of Charlie Kirk. But you'd correctly object if I enforced that opinion with government power.

> Before your ilk became dominant in public discourse…

Yikes.


>They have the clear First Amendment right to do so on their own time.

They don't have a right to a government job.

Are you fine with CPS employees espousing absurd opinions about the fitness of homosexuals to be parents? Because that's the door this opens. Think a few steps ahead.

If you wanna spew politics and keep your LEO or teaching job get elected sheriff or school board.


> They don't have a right to a government job.

They have a right not to be fired from their government job for espousing constitutionally protected speech that doesn't affect their duties. (As affirmed by the Supreme Court, regularly!)

> Are you fine with CPS employees espousing absurd opinions about the fitness of homosexuals to be parents?

No, but "I hate a significant portion of the population in a way that directly relates to my job" and "I didn't like this one specific guy that has nothing to do with my job" are… substantially different things.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: