Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Jumping straight into coding is a very junior thing to do.

Using Plan mode in Cline or other agent based workflows is day and night in the outputs.

Alas, at least in Cline it seems plan mode doesn’t read files just works off context which is insane to me and hinders its usefulness, anyone know why that happens?



> Using Plan mode in Cline or other agent based workflows is day and night in the outputs.

Agreed. My tool agnostic workflow is to work up a planning/spec doc in the docs/feature-plans folder. I use one chat thread to make that. First it creates the basic plan, then then we pick it apart together, I manually fix bad assumptions, then in a new chat, we implement.

Before and after implementation, I run my /gilfoyle command for a constructive roast, then my /sec command for a thorough security review. After implementing this, and a bit more, the final LLM output quality is much higher.

edit: adding "make sure we are applying known patterns used in our app for our solution, don't reinvent the wheel." helped a ton. I am on mobile atm, and that might not be the exact wording.


When it tells me that I need to switch to act mode for it to read files and create a detailed the plan, I just chide gently and ask it to read the damn files in plan mode. Works every time. I wish I dont have to do that.


Cline plan mode doesn't tend to read files by default but you can tell it 'read all files necessary to establish a detailed plan'. GPT5 also seems more eager to read files.


You can just add the files to the prompt with the @ sign.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: