Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Dunno man, I have used Android phones and they are way worse than my iPhone in my opinion - I assume you have an Android phone, so it’s fun we both consider the other ecosystem more aggressively demanding of attention and naggy.

Ultimately I think they both suck and we’ve all gotten used to the one evil we’ve chosen.



The number of authentication and permission prompts is noticeably higher with macOS and iOS, there's really no comparison.


Interesting - I find the opposite, Android much naggier and attention-demanding than iOS. To each their own, I guess.


Which is objectively a good thing, right?


No, not objectively good at all.

If you're a neurotic obsessive who wants to pretend that all kinds of dastardly forces are trying to spy on you and your data, then yes, you want more security checks and more permission prompts.

For literally everyone else - these are only obstacles to their intended use of the device, and every one of them is objectively worse!

Safari prompts me _every single time I use Google_ about whether I want to share my location. I literally couldn't care less whether Google knows this, and I click yes every time, but Apple, in their infinite wisdom, DOES NOT GIVE ME THE OPTION to say "Always Allow". Thanks to some overbearing, self-important privacy dweeb, no doubt, and no leadership at Apple confident enough to override them.


> If you're a neurotic obsessive who wants to pretend that all kinds of dastardly forces are trying to spy on you and your data

I’m a bit confused here. Why do you think it’s pretending or neurotic and obsessive to believe organizations spy on our data?

This has been common knowledge for at least 10 years and is central to many large business models.


It’s neurotic to think that it matters or harms you.


that's crazy, I always deny because I'm already on the damn search results at that point and don't want to repeat the search for little to no benefit.


It can be argued as good the first time. I now have multiple apps that I would like to use on my Mac that I can't rely on because my computer just decides that since they aren't verified developers that it is ok to turn off random permissions to the file system no matter how many times I approve.


Teaching users to mindlessly enter credentials or approve authorization prompts is a bad thing.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: