Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

You clearly aren't familiar. These "universities" are a step above DeVry. They might be worse in that they cost an arm and a leg to attend.

I used to tutor CS students at several different universities during my first two years at college. I would bet my arm that none of the ones I taught from KSU wound up with a career in software.

The student perspective at these schools is that they're there for the credential, not for the learning. Even at the risk of false negatives, I would actively filter out resumes listing schools like these. I would much sooner interview a non-degree holder.



> Even at the risk of false negatives, I would actively filter out resumes listing schools like these.

I am occasionally on hiring committees and use a rubric for ranking candidates. The rubric usually has 8-10 yes/no questions that might be best summarized as "Does this applicant's resume and cover letter indicate that they have actually written code deep enough to 'map' to our requirements?" Some of the rubric may be a little more specific to the actual job role, but the main idea is to filter out what I have come to think of as "aspirational" software developers.

I think one nice thing about the rubric approach is that candidates don't score "prestige" points or get "penalty" points for their specific educational background. Honestly, it seems like a lot of students from many institutions (some quite well known for rigor) are mostly about the "credential, not for the learning." The rubric seems to effectively filter out the less skilled or interested without eliminating skilled candidates with less "sterling" credentials.


I know several graduates of GA State and KSU. Including one KSU grad that works as a software engineer.


I went to SJSU (now KSU) briefly before transferring to a better school (because I slept through all of high school and didn't do any homework) and I did not get the feeling that anyone else in my classes was going to be a successful software engineer. Rather I got the feeling their parents told them to do CS because they really liked video games.

I took a group project game development class and it went beyond doing all the work in the group, I think I did all the work in the class.

Two people I know did graduate then change careers and become successful animators on Archer though.

At GA Tech the quality of students were better, but it mostly seemed to me that it worked by beating everyone to death such that you washed out if you couldn't work nonstop. They still weren't especially good eg not a single other student knew what version control was.


SPSU?


Oh yeah, the similar name overwrote it when I moved to Silicon Valley.

(The area code is also one digit off, 404 vs 408!)




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: