(edit: I don't disagree with her other definitions. I am concerned that she's missed some key points of the larger debate, namely:
* Should "outsiders" be actively encouraged to join
the community, or should the community be insular and
inward-focused?
* Should those who simply want to make a better living
be encouraged to learn about and seek employment in
the industry, given how lucrative careers can be?)
We do not know whether hackers can be born in adulthood because we all weren't.
Regarding your questions there is an answer that fits hacker mentality perfectly: "Your mileage may vary".
Outsiders should try to join the community if they like. Indeed, you can't tell somebody who is "in" the community from the newcomer because in internet people don't wead badges.
Everybody should be encouraged to learn, but discouraged from cheating WRT their level and skills.
